Ask Not for Whom the Recess Bell Tolls: Things I Learned from my Fourth Grade Teacher

Interjection during a chapter of “The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe”:

“C.S. Lewis died the same day that John F. Kennedy was assassinated. One man took us to Narnia, the other started us on our way to the moon. ‘Thus always to dreamers,’ if you’ll let me appropriate from another famous American assassination. None of you know who John Wilkes Booth is?”

Reviewing numbers that include both whole numbers and fractions:

“Here’s a compelling thought. Your life can never be a mixed number. One and one-half? Your life never gets that far. Your life is always simply part of ‘one’. Until it’s over. Then it’s just one over one. Right now, what are you all? Ten years old? That means that most of you are one eighth of the way done with your lives. Just seven eighths left. Some of you, who knows? Quinn? I’ll be amazed if you make it past thirty. So you’re probably one third of the way through. I’ll be astounded if your current fraction is ‘less than’ that.”

During an impromptu lecture about hygiene:

“It’s cold season, and I’m not going to coddle you and make anyone here wash their hands. Let me just say that 36,000 people die every year from complications related to the common cold. Now it’s in your hands. I wash mine every chance I get, since this classroom is thicker with plague than a port city in Italy circa 1348. And that’s a perfect segue into today’s history lesson.”

During a math class later in the year:

“You know, I’m actually wrong about that mixed number thing. Your life can be a mixed number in comparison to other people’s lives. Let’s say you get married and your spouse dies at age sixty. You live to be eighty. Your life is . . . one and two sixths the length of your spouse’s life. Can anyone reduce the two sixths? That’s right, Jess. One and one third the length of your spouse’s life. And what fraction of your own life is that twenty years you spend alone? That’s right. One fourth. You spend one fourth of your life alone.”

Prompted by a single sentence concerning the Thirty Years War in our history text:

“This is the truth, and not something with which this whited sepulcher of a ‘factual’ book would ever trust children. European culture came apart so completely during this time that people ate corpses hanging from gallows, and even babies. And this was only about four hundred years ago. Quinn, you have a small brother, don’t you?”

Under his breath to me, during a game of dodgeball:

“Aim for Quinn. The sooner he develops a taste for defeat, the sooner he’ll achieve the flat line of emotion that passes for human happiness.”

When a student’s mother provided birthday cake and balloons:

“Balloons teach us that we must accept slavery in order to bring happiness to others. And when our buoyant inner resources have leaked away, we’ll be thrown out and utterly forgotten. The intensity with which the balloon bounces at the end of the string in a gale shows us the truth of its despair. Releasing a balloon to the wild results in the balloon’s freedom, which is, however, a pointless freedom. The balloon blows nowhere, has no intentions, bursts and falls like Daedalus’ child when he flies too high. When it comes to a balloon, only one act is merciful: burst it with a pin, so that the extent of its anguish will not burrow into the tissues of your tiny hearts. If you don’t mind, I’ll have another piece of cake, Mrs. Rafferty.”

Ask Not for Whom the Recess Bell Tolls: Things I Learned from my Fourth Grade Teacher

About Your Heart Beating

When Mr. Pennant finished going over the class rules, he told us, “You guys are in fourth grade now. You’re all eight or nine years old. In previous times that’d be a large chunk of your lives on earth.”

He made a face at this, eyes big and corners of his mouth drawn down, to indicate something like ”Impressive.” We’d all gotten to know Mr. Pennant a little bit in previous years—he lead our daily assemblies—and were excited to be in his class. Older siblings told us he was fun.

“Nine years would be about one-quarter of your life. By the way, are you guys ready for fractions?” He smiled wide and jumped his eyebrows up and down. We laughed.

“In a previous age, most of you wouldn’t even be here. Not just at a decent private school. I mean alive. Most of you would be dead. You, Chris, you’d never have made it. Tiffany, there’s just no way. Life was hard and brutish and short and usually ended in your early childhood. Making it this far would have been an accomplishment.

“Your parents would have buried you. You’d be underground, still and silent, eyes closed, full of worms. And that is exactly where you’re headed. I just heard myself say that, and it sounds like a threat. It shouldn’t sound like a threat. I don’t mean it to sound that way at all. I’m headed the same way. You’re born, life is a struggle, and you die. We suffer our days away and then die, go back to the earth. Your bodies aren’t even at the height of their powers yet, but they’re still just looking for opportunities to fail you. Especially you, Chris.”

He went to the front of the classroom and wrote on the board.

“As for man, his days are as grass.
As a flower of the field, so he flourisheth.
For the wind passeth over it, and it is gone,
and the place thereof shall know it no more.”

He wrote it and spoke it in that weird staccato pace your voice does to match your hand, like it’s running alongside of a horse.

“That’s the bible. Not only do you die, you will be forgotten. Put your hand on your heart. Not for the pledge of allegiance. I want you to feel your heart. 100,800 beats per day. Now think about your heart beating. All it has to do is stop. Why is it beating anyway? You don’t control it. You can’t talk it into continuing to beat. If it stops, it just stops. If you learn one thing this year, I want you to learn that. Death is a wave and it is rolling toward you even now. I want you to learn that. But you know what?”

He held one finger up. He smiled.

“Now it’s story time.”

We had a substitute the next day, and for the next two weeks, and then we had Ms. Cressler for the rest of the year.

About Your Heart Beating